Chevron left icon
All Insights
Calendar icon
November 20, 2026
Product

The primary banking interface battle: AI Agents vs Incumbents

Jordan Wright

Co-founder and CEO

A market reversal

For years we have seen companies embedding financial services. What happens when that trend reverses and those same players get embedded in financial services? What happens when players embed anyone and everyone?

The advent of personal AI agents

Over the last year we've had a unique opportunity to see this unfold because we're enabling aspects of it at Atomic Financial, but these initiatives are picking up speed in the last month or two. The acceleration is largely due to the launch of always on personal AI agents like Muse, Instinct, Grok Bots, Claude Duet and more.

Consider the following comment by Tim Spence, CEO of Fifth Third Bank.

We’re going to take every valuable service that you can get done on Muse, whether that’s looking at subscriptions and finding opportunities to generate savings or budgeting or otherwise, and we’re all going to build them into our apps. And the benefit you’ll get then is investment grade or bank grade information security as a perimeter and no blending between the information that exists in your financial graph with the information that exists in your social graph. (Tim Spence, CEO Fifth Third Bank - Q3 2026 earnings call)

This single public comment is repeated - in spirit - by many of the largest FI's and Fintechs in the country right now.

Horizontal vs Vertical

There are currently two prevailing views on who wins the right to consumer and small business in banking over the next 1-3 years.

First, the believers in the horizontal model. They believe OpenAI, Muse and Claude are going to dominate consumer finance. The reasons they cite?

  • Consumer inattentiveness arbitrage - "I fight for the users" (Tron) This group believes that by operating across verticals on behalf of users they will win the hearts and minds and banks / fintechs will become a thing of the past, a layer that is obfuscated away. Many big banks and fintechs have been making money off consumer inattentiveness / laziness for years. They pay you tiny percentages of interest and make a large spread. The big banks are perhaps the safest place to keep money and it takes effort to try and optimize so users have let their laziness become the large FI's opportunity.
  • Speed to market - these horizontal players can iterate so quickly that they'll be able to pull off massive change in short periods of time. The market will shift under the feet of these overweight incumbents and they'll wake up one morning to find out they're no longer the primary banking interface, it has shifted to the horizontal players.
  • Data access - with 1033 protection, these horizontal players will come in and grab whatever data they want whenever they want to work on the consumers behalf to help them improve their finances. They never stop working on this goal for the user and every bit of data emboldens them on their mission. Beyond 1033 they're going on to do so many other interesting things in the data connectivity world, offering connections for taxes, subscription management, etc.

Next, the believers in the vertical model. They believe main players in the market today (insert list of top banks and fintechs, you know who they are) will not only not go down without a fight, they'll emerge victorious in the fight to be the primary banking interface of their clients.

  • Customer relationships - more and more big bank executives are doubling down on learning the language of the consumer. PNC's incoming CFO Alex Overstrom is one that talks about "client obsession" and PNC even has a "Chief Hospitality Officer." The customer already comes to them for their finances. Wouldn't it be natural for customers to come to them first?

  • Money movement - while it stands to reason that data will continue to open up across all of financial services, it doesn't stand to reason that banks will let bots manage transferring money from a consumers account willy nilly. Yes, there will be agentic commerce, but unlimited agentic bank to bank transfers? That's an entirely different risk story. I don't think it's in the best interest of consumers to actually enable this at scale.

    Data access - this data accessibility is now a two-way street. Five years ago "embedded banking" was all the rage. Now the talk is shifting. What if banks were to embed merchant functionality into banking? We're seeing examples of this everywhere and it's changing how consumers view their bank and fintech partners. The big banks also have a point when they say that major data players have not always shown themselves to be good stewards of the data at their disposal.

Clearly, both sets of players have reasons to believe they can win. I assume it will turn into more of a "it depends" outcome, which is a little infuriating for those of us that like tight lines and everything in its place. However, it is clear to me that the players that successfully become the primary banking interface - in the branch, on mobile, online - will win the consumers attention by helping the consumer win when it comes to their finances.

In the past year I've come to the conclusion that we'll see a resurgence of primary banking relationships as people go "all-in" on a single provider that offers them everything they need to manage their finances. The next year or two is going to cement relationships that are going to be more concentrated than they've been in the last 10-20 years as financial institutions, fintechs and horizontal players battle it out for the best experience for their customers.

How the winners win

When you have a deeper view into the financial life of a consumer you can look out for them in ways you never could before. You can delight them in ways you never could before. You can drive primacy in ways you never could before.

A quick example can be helpful here. During a recent very typical payment switch for an airline company, Atomic identified that the user had $720 in eCredits that were scheduled to expire in the next two weeks. So, in addition to helping the consumer put their new credit card on file with a merchant they'd used over the years they now had the ability to look out for that consumers best interest by sharing, "by the way, did you know you have $720 of eCredits that expire in two weeks?" Now that's hospitality. That's going to bat for your customer.

As a consumer, my primary banking interface changed this year. I now use a financial app that allows me to see my money across all the financial institutions I engage with, manage my relationships with my top merchants without ever leaving the banking interface and proactively brings up improvements to how I could approach my money with a simple "tap yes" if you'd like me to do this for you. I can view my Costco receipts. Start a return or purchase an item again with Amazon. I can see my current available points balance at my top merchants. I can pause, cancel or re-enable subscriptions. I see when I need to book my next flight in order to avoid my eCredits expiring. It helps me understand how much I should pay in quarterly tax payments to stay ahead of tax obligations. I'm all-in on this financial app. I don't even open my other financial app's anymore because they pale in comparison.

When you look at the major use cases for the personal agentic systems, most of them can be rolled out by a financial institution or fintech. Maybe not all of them belong in your primary banking interface, but many do. They're spending gobs of money throwing AI use cases at consumers. We get to watch what works then turn it around quickly enough to give customers delightful experiences in the apps and with the financial brands they already trust, know and use today.

Summary

Banks and fintechs have a right to win the primary banking interface battle. They need to do what they've historically done well, but they also need to develop the winning experiences the horizontal players are offering their customers and hopefully develop even better use cases themselves.

To see some of these experiences in practice, check out the video on our YouTube.

Ready to bring these experiences to your customers? Schedule time with our team today.

Read more insights

View all insights

Unlock the action layer of your financial app

To connect with us, please fill out the form. Expect a response within one business day.

Contact sales

Reason

By submitting this form, you agree that your information is collected in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Our team has received your message.

Here's what to expect for next steps: